Biology 100/101
Lecture 25
Macroevolution: Speciation
(Print Version)

Announcements

Objectives

Web Resources

What is Macroevolution?

Evolution is a Fact

What is a Species?

How do New Species Arise?

Reproductive Isolation

Geographic Relationships

Allopatric Speciation

Parapatric Speciation

Sympatric Speciation

Example of Speciation

Speciation and Time

Extinction

Lecture Syllabus

IB 100/101 Home Page


Announcements

Text Readings in Lewis et al.

Chapter 17, Speciation and Extinction

Much of the material cited in this lecture outline came from your textbook (Lewis et al). It is highly beneficial to read these chapters carefully before your final exam.

The "Reviewing Concepts" boxes are valuable summaries of the main ideas in these sections of the text.

You have open access (no log-in or password needed) to instructional materials on the Text web site. Select the text chapter you want and use the links to the e-learning modules or other available materials. There is also a collection of study materials called the "Essential Study Partner" that you may find useful.

Web Crossing

You may also ask questions and see answers to your classmates' questions in Web Crossing in the "Talk to Sarah and Ed" discussion.

Objectives:

The content of today's lecture will help you complete these assignments:

After studying this material you should be able to:

  1. Distinguish between macroevolution and microevolution.

  2. Explain why evolution is considered both a fact and a scientific theory.

  3. Discuss the limitations of the biological species concept, and why a species definition is important.

  4. Explain the importance of geographic isolation in the formation of a species.

  5. Explain the concept of geographic isolation in terms of islands and barriers.

  6. Explain the different ways reproductive isolation can occur and provide examples.

  7. Explain how reproductive isolation is involved in the formation of a species.

  8. Distinguish among allopatric, parapatric, and sympatric speciation.

  9. Explain how speciation can occur within the same geographic region as the parental population (without geographic isolation).

  10. Describe what a phylogeny is.

  11. Know these terms and the relationships among them:

    12. species macroevolution natural selection
    geographic isolation reproductive isolation ecological isolation
    temporal isolation mechanical isolation behavioral isolation
    prezygotic reproductive isolation postzygotic reproductive isolation polyploid
    speciation theory hybridization
    adaptive radiation phylogeny mass extinction
    allopatric speciation parapatric speciation sympatric speciation

Web Resources:

What is Macroevolution?

Evolution as a Fact AND a Theory

    Evolution, the change in the genetic composition of a population over time or the development of new species and extinction of previously existing species is FACT.

    • Evolution has occurred; it still is occurring; it has been directly observed, documented, demonstrated, and described. Supporting evidence for it is overwhelming (and obtained from a wide range of scientific fields).

    The mechanisms by which we think evolution occurs (e.g., natural selection, mutation, genetic drift) are SCIENTIFIC THEORIES that explain these observed changes in living organisms over time.

    • Several theories to explain evolution have been proposed and debated by evolutionry biologists. It is far from clear how evolution proceeds in every detail or in every case, but the Fact that evolution has occurred is not questioned by the majority of biologists.

      • Recall Lecture One, Science as a Way of Knowing the Natural World. Once a hypothesis has been supported by many experiments and/or observations it is considered by the community of scientists to be a theory. (Note that this is very different from the common use of the word, meaning an opinion or a guess.)

      In summary, Darwin established the FACT of evolution, and proposed a THEORY, natural selection, to explain the mechanism of evolution.

    • If you are interested in the relationship of science and religion concerning the topic of evolution I invite you to consult these sources for further discussions.

What is a Species?

As with our earlier discussion of species diversity, the biological definition of species is important in the discussion of MACROEVOLUTION.

When we talk about the evolution of new species from pre-exixting species we need some criterion to determine when we are seeing a new species

  • The Biological Species Concept is the definition Lewis et al. use in your text.

    • Species - "A group of similar individuals that breed sexually in nature only among themselves [produce fertile offspring], or a microorganism with a distinctive set of features. (Lewis et. al. glossary, pg 972)

    • Some Limitations to the Biological Species Concept (others exist)

      • Restricted to sexually reproducing organisms, so it does not apply to single celled organisms that reproduce by simple cell division (mitosis).

      • Some species are incredibly variable; different species can be virtually identical.

      • Does not fit many plant species because they freely form hybrids.

      • No clear application to the fossil record, since reproductive isolation does not show up in fossilized materials.

    • DNA sequence comparisons can be used to assess relatedness of organisms, and is useful in assigning organisms to species when no other information is available.

    • Our definitions of species can change as our ability to detect differences among types of organisms changes.

New Species and Reproductive Isolation

The key to understanding the formation of new species is understanding how a population becomes reproductively isolated from other populations of the same species. Think of this as the isolation of gene pools (all the genes and their alleles in a population).

    Understanding speciation is based on understanding HOW two populations can become genetically different enough to become unable to reproduce with each other.

    If populations are not reproductively isolated, gene flow between the populations maintains their genetic similarity and they maintain the ability to interbreed, so new species do not form.

    Populations that are not reproductively isolated may change genetically over time--they evolve (microevolution) --but those changes are shared among the populations by gene flow so they remain as one species.

    "Evolution's human and chimp twist". (from BBC News) Gene flow between early humans and chimpanzees?

The rest of this outline describes the various ways in which this gentic reproducive separation can happen.

Genetic Changes that Lead to Reproductive Isolation of Populations

New species arise when genetic differences accumulate to the point when the two populations can no longer successfully mate and reproduce. (Remember: species can be defined as "A group of similar individuals that breed sexually in nature only among themselves [produce fertile offspring]....."

For new species to form, reproductive isolation is necessary. Genetic changes can lead to a variety of isolating mechanisms. Some of these differences are the result of single gene mutations.

Odd fly uncovers evolution secret Resource found by Tara Frey.

Reproductive Isolating Mechanisms: (from text, fig. 17.4, pg 306)

  • Premating or Prezygotic (isolating mechanisms that prevent the union of gametes; it occurs before or during fertilization)

    • Mechanical Isolation. Mating organs do not fit [or are adapted for different pollinators].

    • Ecological Isolation. The two populations require different micro-habitats in the same general area.

    • Seasonal and Temporal Isolation. Populations are reproductively active or fertile at different times of year or day.

    • Behaviorial (or Ethological) Isolation. Different preferences or behaviors affect mate selection.

    • Gametic Isolation. Mating may be attempted, but the gametes cannot combine.

    • Chromosomal Isolation. Gamete chromosomes from the two parents are not compatible, so fertilization can not occur even if gametes can fuse.

  • Postmating or Postzygotic (mechanisms that reduce the viability or fertility of hybrid offspring)

    • Hybrid Inviability. Gametes combine, but development cannot produce a viable embryo.

    • Hybrid Infertility. Offspring lack the ability to make or deliver viable gametes. (Horse X Donkey = Sterile Mule, due to different chromosome numbers of parents; mitosis occurs normally, but meiosis is impossible)

Geographic Relationships in the Process of Speciation

In some instances, two populations are isolated in different geographic locations so that initial reproductive isolation of two populations is affected by geographic isolation.

Subsequent genetic changes resulting from the forces of natural selection, genetic drift, migration, nonrandom mating, and mutation in the two geographically isolated populations can, but don't necessarily, result in reproductive isolation and the evolution of new species.

In other examples, genetic changes can occur in two groups within the same or adjacent habitats and produce reproductive isolation and new species.

A common misconception is that formation of new species requires geographical isolation. Geographic isolation may be involved, but that is not always the case.

The important criterion is that there must be reproductiove isolation and that CAN occur without geographic isolation.

    Allopatric Speciation

    allo = other; and patric has to do with country, as in patriot - a person who loves one's country. Allopratric speciation is literally speciation that occurs in different countries.

      Members of two newly formed populations cannot interbreed because they are geographically separated.

      Think of this as the concept of islands and barriers:

      • Islands of land in a sea of water

      • Islands of water in a sea of land

      • Islands of trees in a sea of grass

      • Islands of coolness in a sea of heat

      • Islands of warmth in a sea of cold

      • Islands of nature in a sea of humanity

      • Mountains as barriers

      • Rivers and canyons as barriers

    • Evolution of Salamanders in California from Judgment Day: Intelligent Design on Trial from NOVA on PBS.

    • Stages in the formation of a new species (from Grant, 1963 and 1981, and the University of Alabama).

    • Illustrative example of Allopatric Speciation from the University of Alabama. This figure shows the separation of two populations by some geographic barrier over time. Subsequent divergence leads to the formation of different species. The species are reproductively isolated when that barrier is removed.

    • If a population should become divided into two by a geographic barrier (or if some individuals are transported to a new area outside the parent population's range), evolution of each new population continues independently due to the forces of natural selection, genetic drift, migration, nonrandom mating, and mutation. With time, genetic differences between the two populations gradually accumulate. These genetic differences may result in different reproductive requirements, leading to the reproductive isolation of the populations.

    • Microevolution becomes macroevolution once a population divides and sufficient genetic divergence between the groups occurs so that if they once again come in contact, they could no longer produce fertile offspring (i.e., they are different, yet closely related species).

      • Allopatric speciation: The formation of new species when two populations are physically separated by a geographic barrier, such as this illustration of white and brown tamarin monkey populations on different sides of the Amazon River (Text figure 17.5, pg 308).

    Parapatric Speciation

    Para = alongside

      The formation of a new species when populations inhabit neighboring areas but mate mostly among themselves, such as seen in these tropical little greenbul birds (Text figure 17.6, pg 309).

    Sympatric Speciation

    Sym = same

      Geographic isolation is NOT always necessary for speciation to occur.

      Genetic changes can occur in some individuals in a population that result in their reproductive isolation from the rest of the population.

      Speciation can occur within the range of the parent population (and sometimes quite rapidly).

      Gene flow may be disrupted by several types of genetic change:

      • Genetic changes that affect the form of the reproductive structures in some individuals.

      • Genetic changes that affect the physical characteristics that are important in mate selection in some individuals.

      • Genetic changes that affect behaviors that are important in mate selection in some individuals.

      • Genetic changes that affect the time of reproduction in some individuals.

      • Genetic changes that affect the ability of gametes to fuse in some individuals.

      • Genetic changes that affect the chromosome numbers or compatibility in some individuals.

        • Polyploidy - individuals have multiple SETS of chromosomes that prevent sexual reproduction.

        • autopolyploid - extra chromosome sets occur from matings within the from the SAME species. Mistakes in meiosis or mitosis produce zygotes with multiple sets of chromosomes.

        • allopolyploid - extra chromosome sets occur from matings of DIFFERENT species through hybridization)

        • These polyploids can self-fertilize or breed among themselves.

        • In humans and other animals, polyploidy is lethal. In plants, polyploidy is quite common. It has given rise to many new species. It is estimated that as many as 50% of extant flowering plant species have evolved via hybridization and polyploidy.

      • Choice of host plant or habitat (the utilization of different resources)

        • The natural host of the American fruit fly is a hawthorn tree; however, some flies live in apple trees. By eating, courting, mating, and laying their eggs on different host plants, the two groups of flies have become reproductively isolated from one another and are on their way to becoming different species. Genetic differences between these groups can be measured.

        • In many organisms, shifts to new host plants or habitats trigger phenotypic changes that lead to new species.

    An Example of Speciation by Hybridization and Polyploidy Tragopogon

  • Three species of salsify (vegetable oyster) were introduced from Europe.

    • T. dubius, T. porrifolius, and T. pratensis

  • All three species occur in SE Washington and adjacent Idaho, in an area known as the Palouse.

    • Only T. dubius and T. pratensis occur in Illinois and they are not that common, mostly road-side weeds.

  • When two or more species co-occur, natural hybrids are found.

    • However, these hybrids are sterile.

    • In 1949, fertile individuals were discovered! These are new species, because they can not hybridize with any of the original three species. They have twice the number of chromosomes as the original three species. The relationships among these species can be seen in the "Tragopogon Triangle"

Speciation and Time

An evolutionary tree (or phylogeny), depicting rates and times of speciation and extinction events. Evolution occurs in a branching pattern, with one species giving rise to others as they occupy and adapt to new habitats. They descend from an original ancestral form, much as the branches on a tree arise from the same trunk. (Text figure 17.9, pg. 311)

    A phylogeny depicts species' relationships based on descent from shared ancestors.

    Adaptive Radiation: the divergence of several new types of organisms from a single ancestral type. When a population faces an environment with abundant and diverse resources (such as the opening up of many new habitats), a burst of speciation can occur if members of a population inherit a structure or ability that gives them an advantage.

    Speciation events lead to the multiplication and diversification of species into higher taxa (e.g., genera, families, orders, classes, phyla, etc.). All species (animals, plants, fungi, and all major groups of microorganisms) can be traced back to a single origin of life on earth. Evolution is a continuing process that explains the history of life on earth, as well as the diversity of life today.

Species Extinctions

Extinction: the disappearance of a species, or the inability of a species to adapt to a particular environmental challenge.

  • Decreased genetic diversity may lead to extinction of populations and, eventually, the species.

  • The history of the earth is punctuated by several mass extinctions (see (text table 17.1, pg. 316)). Mass extinctions have periodically opened up vast new areas for adaptive radiation to occur.

  • As mentioned in the biodiversity lectures, the number of organisms on Earth is now being reduced at a rate 1,000-10,000 times higher than any time prior to the evolution of humans (that is, a few decades or centuries rather than millions of years)